|
|
|
World Trade Center catastrophe
safety and health links archive |
|
|
September, October, November
2001 |
|
| |
NYCOSH's 9/11-related work is
conducted in partnership with the United Church of Christ's National Disaster Ministries,
with additional support from the September 11th Fund created
by the United Way of New York City and the New York Community Trust.
In addition, some more recent links will be found on the NYCOSH home page.
Where possible, these links are grouped by subject, such as Compensation or Asbestos, with non-specific links categorized as News or Occupational Safety and Health Resources. Within each subject, the newest listings are at the top.
NYCOSH cannot guarantee the accuracy or completeness of the information in the external links below.

For links concerning biological weapons (including anthrax) and biosafety, click here.
Occupational and environmental
safety and health hazards have an effect on everyone, going far
beyond the concerns resulting from the World Trade Center catastrophe
or bioterrorism. For more information on the identification,
control and elimination of workplace and workplace-related hazards,
and to learn more about the struggle to ensure that every workplace
is safe and healthful, please explore the our extensive website
and its 2000 links to other Internet resources on the subject.
To visit our site map, please click here.
|
|
| |
indicates that a link is only available in Adobe Portable Document
Format.
For information about using PDF files, click
here. |
|
| |

Asbestos (Sept. - Nov. 2001)
For
links to more recent publications, click
here.
- Summary
Report: Characterization of Particulate Found in Apartments After
Destruction of the World Trade Center
At the request of a informal committee of elected officials,
two environmental scientists took indoor dust and air samples
near the WTC site. They found high levels of asbestos in many
of the samples, and recommended that all WTC dust be treated
as asbestos-contaminated unless tested and shown to be asbestos-free.
- Feds, City Ignore Asbestos Cleanup Rules,
Says EPA Vet
A veteran scientist at the federal Environmental
Protection Agency is charging that her agency and the city Health
Department are ignoring federal asbestos-abatement law in buildings
around the World Trade Center disaster site. In a scathing memo
circulated last week within the agency, Cate Jenkins, a 22-year
EPA employee, charged that top brass have "effectively waived"
the EPA's "strict national regulations for removal and disposal
of asbestos contaminated dust" by recommending that residents
and commercial building managers in lower Manhattan follow the
"extremely lenient (and arguably illegal) asbestos guidelines
of the New York City Department of Health." In her memo,
a copy of which was obtained by the Daily News, Jenkins noted
that the EPA's testing had identified at least 30 locations,
some five to seven blocks from Ground Zero, where asbestos levels
in dust samples were above the 1% "action level" cited
in the federal Clean Air Act. (Daily News, November 20, 2001)
- Asbestos Taints Workers' Refuge Exhausted firefighters and
cops their lungs hurting from the thick air around the
collapsed World Trade Center wandered into the nearby
Embassy Suites hotel on Sept. 11 looking for a place to sleep
and something to eat. For the next five days, the evacuated hotel
served as a refuge for dozens of the city's Bravest and Finest
and handfuls of volunteer rescue workers. It may not have been
the best place to go. (Daily News, November 20, 2001)
- Asbestos Higher in Newer Test Asbestos contamination inside buildings near the
World Trade Center site may be far worse than government officials
have reported, according to a new study by a top private toxicology
firm. (Daily News, October 9)
- Bulk Dust Monitoring for Asbestos U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
data from 89 lower Manhattan locations.
- Is Ground Zero Safe? New study suggests
more asbestos at disaster site than previously revealed In the weeks since the World Trade Center
was attacked, evidence is mounting that large quantities of asbestos
were showered down on lower Manhattan. The U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency, which has 16 stationary air-quality reading
stations throughout ground zero and has been studying the debris
regularly, has said that 34 dust samples (out of 128 studied)
and a handful of air readings have been positive for significant
asbestos. But a new study by independent researchers suggests
even more asbestos was released than those EPA tests have revealedand
in a potentially more dangerous form. (Newsweek, October 5)
- OSHA Asbestos Sampling Area Map - Lower
Manhattan and World Trade Center (Samples September 13th through 27th, 2001)
- Asbestos Use in the Construction of the
World Trade Center
In light of the devastation and horror
of the tragedies which took place in NY and Washington, there
will be many questions raised about the construction of the twin
towers and the performance of the fireproofing materials used.
It is a time to reflect and review; to identify ways in which
we can protect our citizens and the infrastructure of our countries.
This must be done with open minds and all the technological and
scientific innovation we can muster. Do not let us get misdirected
by a smokescreen of blame and misunderstanding. (International
Ban Asbestos Secretariat, September 19)
- Asbestos Monitoring
Links to EPA data from 17 lower Manhattan locations
- Asbestos Safety Information for the World Trade
Center
(White Lung Association)
- Asbestos Targeted In Cleanup Effort Hundreds of asbestos cleanup
workers representing more than a dozen local unions and several
contractors continued the massive and delicate task of removing
the contaminant yesterday from buildings damaged by the collapse
of the World Trade Center. In the meantime, Christine Todd
Whitman, head of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, said
yesterday that "there is no reason for concern," saying
that the latest measurements of debris and air at ground zero
and in areas tested in the financial district show the amount
of asbestos is at or below background levels, which she defined
as 1 percent or less of the total sample.(Newsday, September
16)
- Asbestos Alert: How much of the chemical
does the World Trade Center wreckage contain? Nearly four days after the World
Trade Towers collapse sent massive columns of dust andsmoke over
lower Manhattan and into the shifting winds around New York Harbor,
there is still no clear picture of how much asbestos or other
hazardous materials may have been set free into the environment,
officials say. (Newsweek, September 14)
- Asbestos An annotated archive of information
about asbestos in the NYCOSH website and elsewhere on the Internet.
- Asbestos
links
More than 40 Internet sites with detailed information about asbestos
as an occupational health hazard
- Asbestos in the News It didn't start with the World
Trade Center

Breaking news (Sept. - Nov. 2001)
For
links to more recent publications, click
here.
- Major Oil Spills at Ground Zero More than 130,000
gallons of oil from transformers and high-voltage lines
most of it containing low levels of hazardous PCBs were
lost at the World Trade Center on Sept. 11 when two downtown
Con Edison substations were destroyed. In addition to the Con
Ed release, confirmed by company spokesman Mike Clendenin, the
Port Authority is unable to account for 50,000 of 70,000 gallons
of diesel and fuel oil stored in belowground tanks at the Trade
Center complex to power emergency generators. (Daily News, November
29)
- Airing Their Health Concerns: Want Agency
to Watch Ground Zero Area
Frustrated by conflicting reports on
the air quality of lower Manhattan, a group of city and state
officials yesterday called for the establishment of a new agency
to oversee environmental monitoring around the still-smoldering
remains of the World Trade Center. (Newsday, November 27)
- More Ground Zero Air Studies Urged State agencies should be doing more to determine
whether there are any potential long-term health risks from the
air around the World Trade Center site, Assembly leaders said
yesterday. (Daily News, November 27)
- The Unemployed: Ground Zero Cleanup Jobs
Prove Slow to Materialize
A city-financed program seeking work
for welfare recipients and dislocated workers has recruited at
least 150 people for $9-an-hour cleanup jobs at or near the World
Trade Center site. Recruiters at the program, Training Solutions
Inc., said that they had told the people who signed up that they
should be willing to work 12- hour shifts in the rubble and amid
toxic fumes. But the jobs those recruiters were hired to fill
have not yet materialized, and the exact nature of the work is
unclear. (New York Times, November 22)
- Public Distrusts Gov't Air Tests Government agencies
monitoring the air quality near Ground Zero have lost much of
their credibility with the public, Environmental Protection Agency
officials and public health experts said yesterday. "I think
the government has collected a lot of information, but it's clear
that some people aren't believing it when they hear it,"
Dr. George Thurston, an NYU environmental medicine expert, said
during a Pace University panel on the environmental impact of
the Trade Center attacks. (Daily News, November 21)
- Safety Guidelines Set For WTC Site Workers:
Dems Seeking Cleanup Czar
Government and union leaders hammered
out guidelines on safety for Ground Zero workers yesterday as
a group of elected officials urged Mayor Giuliani to name an
environmental cleanup czar for downtown. "We want the workers
to be safe," said Donna Miles, a spokeswoman for the federal
Occupational Safety and Health Administration. While not all
the details of the agreement were available yesterday, the pact
will require workers to complete a health and safety training
program. (Daily News, November 20)
- An Ill - Wind - in Their Lungs Firefighter
Palmer Doyle was planning for the future yesterday. The "World
Trade Center cough" could be heard in firehouses across
the city, and Doyle was in a law office a few blocks from Ground
Zero talking over a lawsuit on behalf of those with the ailment.
"This isn't about money," Doyle said. "It's about
our future and the future of our families." Doyle got the
cough working non-stop for the first several days after the terrorist
attack on the World Trade Center. "We weren't given the
proper equipment for about two weeks," said Doyle, who,
like many other firefighters, wore a paper mask during the early
rescue efforts. "You know what those masks stop?" firefighter
Joseph Sardo said in the kitchen of Engine 10, Ladder 10, which
the city now wants to close. "Golf balls." (Newsday,
November 15)
- Cleanup Worries: Residents, doctors see
WTC health risks
The air quality and round-the-clock
cleanup near the World Trade Center has left many residents near
there sick and traumatized, according to testimony at a City
Council hearing yesterday. According to residents of the area,
as well as doctors and other experts, the environmental risks
near Ground Zero are far greater than what the city or the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency say. (Newsday, November 9)
- Downtown Air's Risky, M.D. Warns Despite official
assurances that the air in lower Manhattan is safe to breathe,
an occupational health expert testified yesterday that it is
causing serious respiratory ailments. "We did not anticipate
that we would see this problem to such an extent among those
working or living peripheral to Ground Zero," said Dr. Stephen
Levin, medical director of occupational and environmental diseases
at Mount Sinai Medical Center. (Daily News, November 9)
- Environmental Concerns Aired at City
Council Hearing
Two months after the World Trade Center
attacks, lower Manhattan residents feel that their physical and
mental health have been damaged by the disaster and the cleanup
efforts, a City Council committee was told Thursday. (Associated
Press, November 8)
- Landfill Safety Concerns: PESH probes
complaint of danger to workers sifting rubble The state
Department of Labor yesterday opened an investigation into health
and safety issues at the Fresh Kills Landfill, where hundreds
of police officers are searching for human remains in the World
Trade Center debris, Newsday has learned. The department, which
operates the Public Employee Safety and Health Bureau, began
the investigation after receiving a complaint that "proper
health and safety precautions are not being taken," said
spokeswoman Betsy McCormack. She declined to elaborate, citing
confidentiality rules. (Newsday, November 8)
- Volunteer Travels to New York to Preach
Safety
The last thing
on the mind of many workers digging through the rubble of the
world's worst terrorist disaster is their own health and safety.
That's where Margaret Cunningham comes in. Cunningham, an industrial
hygienist with the Washington Department of Labor and Industries
in Vancouver, returned Sunday after spending a week at the site
of the World Trade Center in New York. Cunningham and six other
state employees were in Manhattan to give a break to employees
of the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration.
(Vancouver, WA Columbian, November 8)
- Safety Becomes Prime Concern at Ground
Zero Ground
zero at the World Trade Center is a landscape like no other.
It is jagged and angular on the surface, with shards of steel
piled upon steel. It is caustic beneath from the smoke of subterranean
fires. And it is emotional always and everywhere, from the reminders
of the lives that were lost. Those same things also make it a
work site like no other in America, and in that it is a dangerous
workplace, first and foremost. (New York Times, November 8)
- HEALTH: Now, WTC Syndrome' New York-area physicians have begun seeing a series
of illnesses among emergency workers and others who were trapped
in the dense plumes of dust and debris on Sept. 11 after the
Twin Towers collapsed. Dubbed World Trade Center Syndrome, the
ailments range from unrelenting coughs and sinus infections to
posttraumatic stress and acute lung traumas, including severe
asthma requiring mechanical respiration. (Newsweek, November
5)
- NY Firefighters Report Illness More than 4,000
firefighters who have been clearing the devastated site of the
World Trade Center bombings are suffering persistent coughs and
chest pain, according to reports in the U.S. (BBC News, October
31)
- WTC's Toxic Exposure a Worry Seven weeks after
the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center about 400,000
tons of rubble and steel have been removed, but the site still
smolders and there is some concern about the dioxins, PCBs, benzene,
sulfur dioxide and lead emitted at the 16-acre site. "We're
highly critical and highly concerned, there's a lack of safety
protective equipment and while some major concerns have been
addressed there is a long way to go," David Newman, an industrial
hygienist with the New York Committee for Occupational and Safety
Health, told United Press International. "These heroes should
not be subject to disease or accidents." (United Press International,
October 28)
- Feds: Rescue Workers Not Protected A federal agency
has slammed the city for not taking steps to protect rescue workers
from injuries immediately after the World Trade Center catastrophe.
In a sharply worded report, consultants for the National Institute
of Environmental Health Sciences said nearly 1,000 injuries
ranging from blisters and nausea to severe burns and fractures
could have been prevented if the city had made sure workers
had basic safety training and equipment such as hardhats and
respirators. "They were taking risks which under the circumstances
were understandable, and those people need to be considered heroes,"
Joel Shufro, executive director of the New York Committee on
Occupational Safety and Health, said yesterday of the firefighters,
paramedics, cops and ironworkers. "But this is no longer
a rescue operation," he said. "What needs to happen
now is that workers need to be protected so they don't suffer
illness or injury. What we don't want to see is a second national
tragedy." (Daily News, October 26)
- A Toxic Nightmare At Disaster Site: Air,
Water, Soil Contaminated
Toxic chemicals and metals are being released
into the environment around lower Manhattan by the collapse of
the World Trade Center towers and by the fires still burning
at Ground Zero, according to internal government reports obtained
by the Daily News. Dioxins, PCBs, benzene, lead and chromium
are among the toxic substances detected in the air and soil around
the WTC site by Environmental Protection Agency equipment
sometimes at levels far exceeding federal levels, the documents
show. (Daily News, October 26)
- Questions About Safety of Workers Hundreds of injuries to workers combing through
the rubble at the World Trade Center might have been prevented
had the city been faster to require proper training and equipment
at what is still an "extremely hazardous" work site,
according to a sharply worded federal report. (Newsday, October
25)
- Local OSHA Veterans Find Hope Amid the
Horror at World Trade Center Death
is no stranger to Michael Laughlin and Vance Delsignore, compliance
officers for the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration.
But even these veterans of workplace tragedies were shocked and
saddened by the enormity of the devastation they experienced
at the field of debris in Manhattan where the World Trade Center
once stood .... The OSHA agents were instructed to advise the
contractors responsible for the demolition work of safety problems
and possible remedies rather than act as enforcers of safety
laws. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette October 18)
- Cleanup Hazards At Ground Zero An Ongoing
Worry: Union Provides Hazmat Training on Site A month after
the twin towers vanished from the Manhattan skyline in blinding
clouds of dust, what's left at ground zero still smokes. Thick
plumes rise from the twisted heaps of ruined steel. The smell
remains difficult to describe but impossible to forget: Faintly
sweet, it tickles the nose and irritates the throat. Workers
at the site compare it to a giant foundry with untold tons of
metal burning under the torch. This smoke is of deep concern
to federal, state and city health officials worried about workers
cleaning up the site. (Washington Post, October 16)
- After Attacks, Studies of Dust and Its
Effects
Despite a steady stream of data from public agencies showing
that the stubborn, eye-stinging plumes of dust from the wrecked
World Trade Center pose few risks, thousands of people
residents and workers in nearby neighborhoods, firefighters,
demolition crews, those who fled the attacks say they
still fear for their health. It's no wonder, given the images
of volcano-size clouds and ghostly coatings of white dust that
are etched in the collective memory of the attacks. And an alphabet
soup of federal, state and city agencies have issued confusing
information on Web sites or in press releases particularly
about asbestos, which was used in building one of the towers
and whose fibers can cause cancer. (New York Times, October 16)
- Something In the Air New Yorkers may now live in dread of bio-terrorism,
but potentially harmful substances already hang in the air over
their city - the smoke and dust created by the World Trade Center
collapse. "It was like trying to breathe in the contents
of a vacuum cleaner bag," says one of the New York detectives
caught in the huge dust cloud thrown up on 11 September as he
shows journalists around Ground Zero. (BBC News Online, October
15)
- Pol's Leery of WTC Air Quality State Sen. David Paterson questioned
official assurances about the air quality in the vicinity of
the World Trade Center ruins, and called for additional environmental
studies to be done on September 10. The Harlem Democrat said
local officials' insistence that the air around Ground Zero is
safe to breathe may be influenced by "well-meaning attempts
on the part of many Americans to return life to the way it usually
is." But he cautioned against hasty judgments. "We
cannot engage in that kind of conduct at the possible expense
of the individuals who live and work there," Paterson said
at a news conference in Bryant Park. "There has never been
a public health crisis like this in the city." (Daily News,
October 11)
- Some still fear environmental hazards
near World Trade Center site Four
weeks after the collapse of the World Trade Center, New Yorkers
are wearing dust masks on the streets downtown and hiring industrial
cleanup crews to remove asbestos from their offices and apartments.
(Associated Press, October 10)
- WTC cleanup triggers safety, cost allegations While much of New York may be
uniting in the wake of the Sept. 11 air attacks, catastrophe
specialists and janitors are engaged in a fierce battle for contracts
to clean offices and apartments covered in dust and debris. (Reuters,
October 10)
- E.P.A. Says Air Is Safe, But Public Is
Doubtful
The Environmental Protection Agency has tested the air
in Lower Manhattan more than 1,000 times and has concluded that
it does not show dangerous levels of contamination. Samples from
the Occupational Safety and Health Administration indicate no
airborne asbestos or other contaminants beyond the disaster site.
And Joel A. Miele Sr., the city's commissioner of environmental
protection, insists that while the air quality can cause nagging
discomfort, "it's not a health concern." (New York
Times, October 6)
- Air Near Ground Zero Is Rated Safe by
Feds
The levels of cancer-causing
asbestos and other material still lingering in the air in lower
Manhattan remain below limits considered a health risk, federal
authorities said yesterday. But with hundreds of tons of hazardous
material still buried among the rubble of the World Trade Center,
experts cautioned workers at Ground Zero to keep wearing respirators.
(Daily News, October 3)
- U.S. finds no significant health hazards
at World Trade Center
Federal health officials who conducted hundreds of tests
at the World Trade Center attack site say they discovered no
significant public health hazards. (Associated Press, October
3)
- Ground Zero: An Environmental Disaster If the cleanup of the Twin Towers
were a simple logistical problem, it could take up to six months
to transfer the 1.2 million tons of rubble to area landfills.
But public-health experts say this is no ordinary trip to the
dump. The 16 acres now known as ground zero are considered the
worst environmental disaster ever inside a major city"the
same scope as a Superfund site," says New York University
Hospital environmental-medicine specialist Max Costa. (Newsweek,
October 1)
- Health Hazards in Air Worry Trade Center
Workers
Ever since the World Trade Center disaster, federal and city
officials have said there is minimal risk from the fetid, dust-filled
air and smoke that continue to envelop Ground Zero. But independent
tests of dust samples around the site have found dangerous levels
of cancer-causing asbestos, fiberglass and even residues
of human bone particles. (Daily News, September 28)
- New OSHA Heads Pushing for Agency To
Take Leadership Role in Advancing Safety Drawing on the agency's work
at the World Trade Center rescue and recovery site in New York
City, the head of the Occupational Safety and Health Administration
Sept. 25 told those attending a national safety meeting that
the agency "must do more than just assure compliance with
standards." (Bureau of National Affairs, September 27)
- Uneasy breathing: As the dust settles
in New York, concerns linger about health risks in the air Two weeks after the catastrophic
attack on the World Trade Center towers, thousands of evacuated
New Yorkers are returning to nearby homes and offices, counting
their blessings that they escaped the disaster. But fires still
smolder downtown and crews continue to sift through the rubble
and carry away debris laden with asbestos and other potential
health dangers. As the dust clears, too, some residents wonder
what else might be in the plume of ash and smoke that exploded
over their city. (MSNBC, September 26)
- OSHA Head Says Rescue Workers' Safety
In New York, Pentagon 'Number One Priority' The Occupational Safety and Health
Administration is "desperately trying to ensure" that
rescue workers are properly protected as they endeavor to deal
with the aftermath of the Sept. 11 terrorist attacks in New York
City and the Pentagon, according to John Henshaw, the agency
head. (Occupational Safety and Health Reporter, September 20)
- Monitors Say Health Risk From Smoke Is
Very Small
The persistent pall of smoke wafting from the remains of the
World Trade Center poses a very small, and steadily diminishing,
risk to the public, environmental officials and doctors said
yesterday. There could be a slight health threat, they said,
to city residents with weakened immune systems, heart disease
or asthma, and to rescue workers who did not wear protective
gear or who smoke. Smoking greatly amplifies the effects of some
kinds of pollution, scientists said. But over all, the danger
was no greater than that on a smoggy day, some officials said.
(New York Times, September 14)
- Fouled Air? Health Officials Stress Caution,
But Say Measured Levels Safe Despite
fires and a pungent odor at the wreckage of the World Trade Center,
most tests for contaminants in New York's air have not triggered
alarm, health officials say. (ABC News, September 13)
- Challenges and Dangers in Disposing of
Two Fallen Giants
New York's twin World Trade Center towers were considered
a triumph of engineering and ambition as they rose in the late
1960's and early 70's. Cleaning up the vast mountain of debris
at the 16-acre site, all that remains of the trade center's dream
after a terrorist attack on Tuesday morning, presents a challenge
no less daunting than the construction itself, engineers and
environmental cleanup experts say. There is also deep uncertainty
about what sorts of environmental hazards may be contained in
the rubble. Asbestos was reportedly not used in the towers as
insulating material for the steel beams. The trade center was
among the first high-rise buildings to use a spray-on ceramic
fire-proofing material instead, according to the National Counsel
of Structural Engineers Associations, a trade group that has
studied the original plans. But officials of the federal Environmental
Protection Agency said yesterday that testing nonetheless showed
elevated asbestos levels in the rubble, perhaps from flooring
materials or other substances. (New York Times, September 13)
- An Invisible Enemy: Dust A hazardous brew of dust, soot,
asbestos and toxic combustion gases will pose a continuing threat
to rescue workers long after the flames are extinguished, environmental
health experts said yesterday. (Newsday, September 13)
- Trade Center Dust Poses
Danger The
huge plume of smoke and grit that spread from the World Trade
Center could trigger attacks of asthma, emphysema and other chronic
lung disease even a day or two after people were exposed, doctors
said September 12. . . . Three preliminary samples already taken
by the agency showed "minimal or no" airborne asbestos,
Whitman said, but a fourth did detect significant levels of the
cancer-causing material. "We're going to take more samples
as time goes on," she said.
(Associated Press,
September 12)

Compensation (Sept. - Nov. 2001)
For
links to more recent publications, click
here.
- Families of Missing Have Three Options To sue or not to sue? "Should
I file a claim with the U.S. government fund? Waive my right
to sue? Should I sue bin Laden? How do I pay the mortgage?"
are the questions that victims' families are asking about compensation
for losses in the Sept. 11 attacks. The magnitude of the tragedy
may explain why few have filed claims with the U.S. fund. There
are no simple answers, but understanding the options may clear
a path for victims' families to get their lives back, financially
and emotionally. (New York Law Journal, November 28)
- Resources: Unemployment, Workers' Compensation
and Related Help
A range of
assistance is available for the survivors of the Sept. 11 terrorist
attacks as well as for the families of those killed and for workers
facing unemployment because of the economic fallout of the disasters.
(AFL-CIO)
- Plan Would Limit City's WTC Liability Mayor Giuliani and Gov. Pataki
had a good reason to support a GOP version of the airline security
bill: It had an eleventh-hour provision that would limit the
city's liability in lawsuits resulting from recovery work at
the World Trade Center site. "The city wants to be exempt
from liability lawsuits from the cleanup, including workers who
might contract lung cancer or anthrax while at the World Trade
Center site," a congressional source said. (Daily News,
November 2)
- Trial Lawyers Care
Non-profit corporation established by the Association of Trial
Lawyers of America to provide free legal services to September
11 attack victims.
- Day Laborers at Ground Zero Say They
Are Not Being Paid
The New York state attorney general's office is investigating
complaints that day laborers hired to clear debris from office
buildings surrounding the site of the World Trade Center have
not been paid, some of them for up to two weeks of work. . .
. . The complaints first surfaced when an organizer with the
New York Committee for Occupational Safety and Health went to
the hiring line to talk to workers about safety precautions;
he heard an earful about how they were not being paid. (New York
Times, October 19)
- Benefits, Assistance and Compensation:
Where to Get Help
A detailed summary for victims of the September 11 disaster
and their families, prepared by the New York State Trial Lawyers
Association (originally posted October 9, updated as needed)
- World Trade Center Tragedy
Creates Complex Workers' Compensation Issues The World Trade
Center tragedy will prove the greatest challenge that has yet
confronted the US workers' compensation system. The horrible
and catastrophic events of September 11, 2001 were never contemplated
in the legislative crafting of our nation's social, remedial
insurance paradigm. Amid grief, sadness and despair, the injured
workers and their dependents are being directed to file claims
through this traditional administrative system, which has been
enhanced by a complicated series of collateral and emergency
entitlement programs. At a difficult time for all Americans,
the road to benefits will be a twisted and byzantine labyrinth.
(New Jersey Law Journal, October 8)
- Victims of the World Trade Center catastrophe are
eligible for many kinds of compensation (NYCOSH, September 28)
- Disaster Unemployment Assistance If you are out of work as a direct
result of the World Trade center Disaster you may qualify for
unemployment insurance even if you would not normally be eligible
(Office of New York State Attorney General Eliot Spitzer)
- Work-Related Injuries and Fatalities:
What You and Your Family Need to Know About Your Benefits (United
States Office of Personnel Management)
- To Families of Union Members Who Died
in the World Trade Center Terrorist Attack (New
York State AFL-CIO Workers' Assistance Bulletin)
- Emergency Assistance - Federal Emergency
Management Agency (FEMA) (New
York State AFL-CIO Workers' Assistance Bulletin)
- Crime Victims Compensation (New
York State AFL-CIO Workers' Assistance Bulletin)
- Crime Victims Board Funding for Funeral
Expenses
(New York State AFL-CIO
Workers' Assistance Bulletin)
- Workers' Compensation (New
York State AFL-CIO Workers' Assistance Bulletin)
- Unemployment Insurance (New
York State AFL-CIO Workers' Assistance Bulletin)
- Social Security Survivors' Benefits (New York State AFL-CIO Workers' Assistance
Bulletin)
- Protect Yourself From Creditors (New
York State AFL-CIO Workers' Assistance Bulletin)
- Assistance for Terrorism Victims Available
from Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA), Justice Department
and Small Business Administration (SBA) (September 18)
- New York State Workers' Compensation
Board World Trade Center Emergency Information & Resources
- NYCOSH Workers' Compensation Index
- Workers'
Compensation Links More
than 30 Internet sites with detailed information about workers'
compensation and injured workers
- Workers' Compensation in the News
It didn't start with the World Trade Center

Government resources
(FOR OFFICIAL
INFORMATION ON A SINGLE SUBJECT, SUCH AS ASBESTOS OR COMPENSATION,
SEE THE SUBJECT)
- Environmental Studies of the World Trade
Center Area After the September 11, 2001 Attack
The information in this report describes the results of an interdisciplinary
environmental characterization of the World Trade Center (WTC)
area following requests from other Federal agencies after the
attack on September 11, 2001. The scientific investigation included
two main aspects: 1) imaging spectroscopy mapping of materials
to cover a large area around the WTC and 2) laboratory analysis
of samples collected in the WTC area. (U.S. Geological Survey,
November 30)
- NIEHS Responds to World Trade Center
Attacks
The buildings
have fallen. The worst of the fires are out. But environmental
health hazards still exist in and around the ruins of the World
Trade Center following the attacks of 11 September 2001. Workers
at Ground Zero toil in a dangerous environment. They and others
exposed to dust and fumes in the wake of the building collapse
and fires may suffer adverse health effects for years to come.
The NIEHS is playing a role in addressing these threats through
four of its ongoing programs--the Worker Education and Training
Program (WETP), the Environmental Health Sciences (EHS) Centers
Program, the Children's Environmental Health and Disease Prevention
Research Centers Program, and the Superfund Basic Research Program.
(Environmental Health Perspectives, November 2001)
- Suggested Guidance for Supervisors at
Disaster Rescue Sites
Including sections on unstable work surfaces, excessive noise,
asbestos dust, heat stress, confined spaces, chemical exposures,
traumatic stress, electrical, carbon monoxide, eye injuries,
flying debris, heavy equipment use and rescuing victims (National
Institute for Occupational Safety and Health)
- Environmental Monitoring Data Related
to the World Trade Center Disaster Response Available to Public:
EPA Invites Public to New Information Repository in Lower Manhattan The U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency has established an information repository containing environmental
monitoring data gathered in response to the World Trade Center
disaster. The information is available at the EPA library located
at 290 Broadway in lower Manhattan, which is the location of
the agency's regional offices. (EPA Press Release, October 30)
- Environmental
Data Trend Report World Trade Center Disaster DRAFT Prepared for U.S. Environmental
Protection Agency Office of Emergency and Remedial Response
(October 29)
- Particulate Matter Fact Sheet
(U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, October 25)
- Response to the World Trade Center (WTC)
Disaster: Initial Worker Education and Training Program Grantee
Response and Preliminary Assessment of Training Needs
(National Institute of Environmental
Health Sciences, October 23)
- National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences
World Trade Center Safety & Health Information
- Disaster Officials Offer Cleanup Tips
For Affected WTC Victims
Federal, state, local and voluntary agency officials recommend
some cleaning tips for people affected by the World Trade Center
attack who are re-occupying commercial buildings and for residents
re-entering their homes. (Federal Emergency Management Agency
press release, October 9)
- Federal Funds Enhance Initiatives Targeting
Respiratory Impacts of WTC Tragedy Governor
George E. Pataki today announced that New York State has received
$8.5 million in federal funds to extend and enhance a variety
of initiatives designed to combat asthma. The Federal funds from
the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), include
a five-year $3.5 million grant, as well as an immediate $5 million
grant for initiatives designed to address any potential respiratory
impacts of the World Trade Center tragedy. (New York State Governor's
Office press release, October 9)
- Air Monitoring in Lower Manhattan Links
to data from more than 30 lower Manhattan locations (NYC Department
of Environmental Protection)
- New York City Department of Health Responds
to the World Trade Center Disaster
- NYC Health Department Responds to Concerns
about Air Quality in Lower Manhattan (October 5)
- Daily Environmental Monitoring Summary (U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency)
- Drinking Water Monitoring
Links to EPA data from 13 lower Manhattan locations
- Particulate Matter 2.5 Monitoring
Links to EPA data from four lower Manhattan locations
- Frequently Asked Environmental and Public
Health Questions about the World Trade Center and Pentagon Tragedies (U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency, September 18)
- Recommendations for People Re-Occupying
Commercial Buildings and Residents Re-Entering Their Homes (New York City Department of Health,
September 17)
- OSHA Pitching In To Assist With Worker
Safety Measures, Asbestos Tests (September 14)

News features (Sept. - Nov. 2001)
For
links to more recent publications, click
here.
- Working Families Mourn, Honor and Rebuild (AFL-CIO
Website)
- News About Workers: Union Members Mourn
Losses, Pray for Survivors Scores of union members worked
in the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, which were attacked
Sept. 11 by terrorist airline hijackers. Hundreds are feared
dead and the fates of many others are unknown. Thousands more
are impacted by massive layoffs and job loss. (AFL-CIO Website)
- With Water and Sweat, Fighting the Most
Stubborn Fire
Jose Maldonado has all the basic tools:
a ladder truck to lift him up and out toward the fire; a pumper
to ensure nearly 800 gallons a minute is poured onto it; and
his respirator, boots and other protective gear to guard against
the roiling waves of heat and toxic smoke. (New York Times, November
19)
- Health Consequences of the 11 September
2001 Attacks
Whenever workers
pick up a steel beam or overturn a piece of rubble, the threat
exists that a puff of asbestos can be thrown into the air and
then inhaled. The long-term health risks of those exposures include
lung cancer and malignant mesothelioma. Risks will be greatest
for those with the most intense and prolonged exposures. Protection
against these risks requires the provision of proper respirators
to workers and the undertaking of health and safety training
programs that emphasize the need for constant wearing of respirators,
for proper fit testing, and for frequent changing and cleaning
of filters. Workers at the site are also at risk of exposure
to silica, lead, benzene, dioxin, and other combustion products.
Dr. Philip Landrigan (Environmental Health
Perspectives, November 2001)
- It's Time to Reward Our Heroes The September
11 terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon
killed over 6,000 people. Union pilots and flight attendants
were the first to die, murdered by the hijackers who commandeered
the planes. Among the thousands killed at the WTC were members
of over twenty different unions, many of whom were the first
on the scene following the massive explosions. Hundreds of union
Firefighters, Police officers and Port Authority officers died
valiantly in rescue attempts. Union healthcare workers, doctors,
nurses and EMTs attended to the injured. Members of the Marine
Engineers and the Seafarers on board the U.S. Navy hospital ship
Comfort joined rescue efforts. After the collapse of the WTC's
Twin Towers and other buildings, 1,000 Iron Workers from throughout
the east coast converged on Manhattan to help in the rescue and
cleanup. Hundreds of New York City Building and Construction
Trades Council members also pitched in. At one point, reported
the New York Times, so many volunteers showed up that authorities
would only let in those with union cards. Meanwhile, unions throughout
the United States have set up relief funds to aid the survivors.
The next time someone tells you that unions are no longer necessary
tell them to say that to the citizens of New York City and to
the workers at Ground Zero. Working people have suffered greatly
in this tragedy but their sacrifice isn't over. The airline industry
has laid off over 100,000 workers, mostly union members. It is
now estimated that the September 11 attacks have cost New York
City 108,500 jobs. The deaths may not be over either. The New
York Committee on Occupational Safety and Health has warned,
"Contaminants in the air, including toxic dust and chemicals,
can cause serious illness or death. Dust and ash anywhere in
the vicinity of the World Trade Center site are likely to contain
asbestos, cement, drywall and polyvinyl chloride combustion products."
- Downwind From Disaster The brave workers on the WTC pile have expressed
concern about the dangers of breathing dust and smoke. Workers
are not currently provided enough information to make an informed
decision about the health risks of the dust and smoke. (New York
Environmental Law and Justice Project)
- Response to the World Trade Center Tragedy Dust created from the collapse of the World Trade
Center and surrounding buildings has found its way into homes
and businesses throughout the region.Scientists have NOT proven
whether this dust is or is not dangerous, but believe that caution
should be used when cleaning your home/business to safely remove
the dust. (Environmental and Occupational Health Sciences Institute
Rutgers University/University of Medicine and Dentistry of New
Jersey)
- A Second Assault Although it is
no longer the focus of international attention, the cleanup at
the World Trade Center continues. In areas of New York City near
the collapsed towers, a layer of dustin some cases more
than six inches thickcovers apartments, offices, and classrooms.
We know that the destruction of the World Trade Center produced
dust and debris containing asbestos, fiberglass, dioxin, PCBs,
silica, volatile organic compounds, and heavy metals such as
lead, cadmium, and mercury. What is not yet clear is what levels
of these chemicals firefighters, police, rescue workers, volunteers
and the public were exposed to and how far the toxic dust has
traveled. Although the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and
Occupational Safety and Health Administration began testing the
air and rubble soon after the collapse of the towers, we may
never know the true impact of this chemically contaminated dust
on rescue workers and the public. (Center for Health, Environment
and Justice)
- The Toxic Aftermath: Facts and Protection for Rescue
Workers and Residents
(September 11 Air
Safety Hazards)
- Three Things We Learned: On Workers,
The Public Sector, and American Exceptionalism
There is no silver lining to the cloud of horror that descended
on America last week. And the avalanche of pain, terror, and
death we have witnessed may be just the beginning. (Tom Paine.Common
Sense, September 22)

Occupational safety and health resources
(Sept. - Nov. 2001)
For
links to more recent publications, click
here.

Psychological trauma (Sept. - Nov. 2001)
For
links to more recent publications, click
here.
- Coping with the Trauma The horror of the World Trade
Center attack continues to haunt Emergency Medical Technician
Bruce Funaro, who was at ground zero Sept. 11 when the Twin Towers
collapsed. "Every day when I drive to work and look out
at where the World Trade Center stood, an empty feeling comes
to my stomach," he said. Mr. Funaro's ambulance post at
Vesey and Church streets was the closest one to the Twin Towers.
On Sept. 11, he saw hundreds of bloodied people with wounds,
burns and terrorized faces running from disaster. Heís
still unable to purge the image of a person with a severed arm
from his mind.
(Public Employee Press,
November 19)
- Managing Traumatic Stress: Tips for Recovering
From Disasters and Other Traumatic Events The September 11th terrorist
attacks were the type of events we thought could never happen.
Like other types of disasters they were unexpected, sudden and
overwhelming. In some cases, there are no outwardly visible signs
of physical injury, but there is nonetheless a serious emotional
toll. It is common for people who have experienced traumatic
situations to have very strong emotional reactions. Understanding
normal responses to these abnormal events can aid you in coping
effectively with your feelings, thoughts, and behaviors, and
help you along the path to recovery. (American Psychological
Association)
- Help With Grief and Trauma (AFL-CIO)
- Traumatic Incident Stress: Information
for Emergency Response Workers (National Institute for Occupational Safety
and Health)
- American College of Occupational and
Environmental Medicine (ACOEM) Resources/Response Guidelines
for Occupational Physicians Who May Deal with Psychological Trauma
in the Workplace as a Result of the September 11 Terrorist Attacks
For reference material
on psychological health, click
here.
Occupational and environmental safety and health hazards have
an effect on everyone, going far beyond the concerns resulting
from the World Trade Center catastrophe or bioterrorism. For
more information on the identification, control and elimination
of workplace and workplace-related hazards, and to learn more
about the struggle to ensure that every workplace is safe and
healthful, please explore the our extensive website and its 2000
links to other Internet resources on the subject. To visit our
site map, please click here.
The “This page was last updated on” line just below reflects the date on which this page was transferred to this redesigned website. The information in this page (as opposed to the design) was last updated on January 9, 2003.
|
|
|