| |

Asbestos
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.
For links material published after January 31, 2002, click
here.
- OSHA Standards Interpretation
Letter Wherever
there is settled dust from the collapse, "proper precautions"
include compliance with the OSHA asbestos standard: "In
that the materials containing asbestos were used in the construction
of the Twin Towers, the settled dust from their collapse must
be presumed to contain asbestos. Therefore [testing of the dust]
is not necessary in order to establish that the applicable provisions
of the Construction Asbestos standard apply during the demolition
or salvage of affected structures."
(January 31)
- Asbestos
Risks Near Ground Zero May Be Far Greater Than Government Reports (St. Louis Post-Dispatch, January 13)
Federal and state officials in New York have grossly underestimated
or played down the number of people in lower Manhattan who are
at risk of being sickened or killed from exposure to asbestos
released in the collapse of the World Trade Center. Evaluations
of analyses done by teams of leading asbestos researchers show
the increased risk of death to people who live, work or study
in homes or offices that have not been properly decontaminated
could be as high as one additional cancer death for every 10
people exposed. For the full text of this article, reproduced
as part of NYCOSH in the News,
click
here, or to view it on the newspaper's own website click
on:

- Decades of Asbestos Deaths
in Montana Mining Town May Help New Yorkers Evaluate Their Risk (St. Louis Post-Dispatch, January 13)
Much of the asbestos-tainted vermiculite that spewed from the
collapsing World Trade Center was dug from a mine in the Cabinet
Mountains above Libby, Montana. And in Libby, as in New York,
environmental and health officials failed to disclose just how
dangerous the mineral could be.

- Preliminary Assessment
of Asbestos Contamination of Lower Manhattan, January 11, 2002, by Cate Jenkins,
EPA Hazardous Waste Identification Division

- Asbestos in Manhattan compared
to Libby Superfund site
- Why cleanup of WTC contamination
is ineffective to date
- Advantages of cleanup under
Superfund statute
- Summary risk assessment for
WTC fallout
- Memorandum, December 19, 2001, by Cate Jenkins,
EPA Hazardous Waste Identification Division

- Wipe sampling for asbestos in
Lower Manhattan
- Projection of airborne levels
from settled WTC dusts
- Estimation of increased cancer
risks based on various WTC dust exposure scenarios
- World Trade Center Asbestos
Memorandum
from Cate Jenkins, EPA Hazardous Waste Identification Division
to Robert Dellinger, Director of EPA Hazardous Waste Identification
Division, December 3
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.

Breaking news (December 2001- January
2002)
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.
For links material published after January 31, 2002, click
here.
- EPA
Official: Lower Manhattan Should Be a Superfund Site (OccupationalHazards.com, January
23) A memo circulating in certain circles casts doubt
on claims made by federal agencies such as the Occupational Safety
and Health Administration (OSHA) and the Environmental Protection
Agency (EPA) that monitoring has not uncovered hazardous levels
of asbestos and other hazards near the World Trade Center (WTC)
site. Ironically, the memo was written by an EPA employee. Are
EPA's Monitoring and Cleanup Efforts at WTC Effective?
(OccupationalHazards.com, January 24) At least one employee of
the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) believes that her agency's
monitoring efforts are falling short in the battle to protect
residents and workers in the area surrounding the World Trade
Center (WTC) site.

- Family Wants Facts In
Death (Newsday,
January 24) The family of a demolition worker who died
a day after being rushed from the teetering Verizon building
at Ground Zero has hired an attorney to determine if the man
perished in a work-related accident. For the full text
of this article, reproduced as part of NYCOSH in the News, click
here, or to view it on the newspaper's own website click
on:

- Senators
Clinton and Lieberman to Hold Hearing on Downtown Air Quality (New York Times, January 20)
Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton and Senator Joseph I. Lieberman
of Connecticut will lead a hearing in the city next month concerning
the air quality at ground zero, particularly the health effects
of early exposure to dust clouds from the trade center collapse,
she announced yesterday.

- EPA
Criticized About Cleanup
(Newsday, January 18) Rep. Jerrold Nadler revealed
yesterday that the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency had its
offices near the World Trade Center professionally cleaned by
an asbestos contractor after Sept. 11, while local residents
were advised to clean with "wet rags."

- Feds
Hit on WTC Cleanup: Nadler Says EPA Double Standard May Pose
Health Risk
(Daily News, January 18) Rep. Jerrold Nadler accused the
Environmental Protection Agency yesterday of grossly mishandling
cleanup efforts after the Sept. 11 attacks, jeopardizing the
health of New Yorkers. Nadler said the EPA had a double standard
recommending that New Yorkers use a wet rag to collect
dust from the twin towers collapse while extensively testing
and professionally cleaning its own offices in lower Manhattan.

- Some See N.Y. Air as a
Hidden Menace: Many Believe EPA Cited Safety Too Quickly (Los Angeles Times, January
18) As New Yorkers choked and gagged under a cloud of
smoky dust after the World Trade Center attacks, the Environmental
Protection Agency constantly assured them that the air did not
pose a major health risk. For the full text of this article,
reproduced as part of NYCOSH in the News, click
here, or to view it on the newspaper's own website click
on:

- U.S.
Agency Not Protecting Public Health, Officials Say (New York Times, January 18)
The Federal Environmental Protection Agency failed to
protect the public health by not focusing more attention on indoor
air quality, which continues to be a nagging issue for thousands
of residents and workers near the World Trade Center site, a
group of elected officials from New York City said yesterday.

- WTC
Cleanup Worker Died
(Newsday, January 18) A man performing cleanup
in the weeks after the World Trade Center attack died at a hospital
a day after being rushed from his work site with complaints of
dizziness, officials said yesterday. His employer did not report
the incident until six days after he was taken to the hospital
and ultimately was fined $100. For the full text of this
article, reproduced as part of NYCOSH in the News, click
here, or to view it on the newspaper's own website click
on:

- WTC-Area Laborers Not
Getting Much Help: Clinic Finds Safety Precautions Are Often
Lacking for Immigrant Workers Wading Through the Dust and Debris
Near Ground Zero
(Staten Island Advance, January 18) After Sept.
11, Omar Jaime and Sara Casa joined a legion of immigrant workers
in Downtown Manhattan cleaning offices coated with dust and debris
from the World Trade Center collapse. Although they had heard
the dust could contain contaminants, they claimed their employers
told them it was safe to clean without protective equipment.
For the full text of this article, reproduced as part of
NYCOSH
in the News, click
here, or to view it on the newspaper's own website click
on:

- Clinic Finds Safety Precautions Are Often
Lacking for Immigrant Workers Wading Through the Dust and Debris
Near Ground Zero
(Staten Island
Advance, January 18)
- Toxic Cover-up: Asbestos,
Lead, Mercury, Dioxin. World Trade Center Syndrome Today, we will meet a doctor
who has treated a parade of Ground Zero patients . . . a lawyer
working on behalf of police union activists investigating why
so many cops are coughing . . . a parent whose son goes to Stuyvesant
High School, blocks from Ground Zero, where kids are suffering
nosebleeds and other respiratory problems . . . organizers who
started a free mobile health unit to treat the hundreds of sick
workers . . . and a woman who was sent to the emergency room
twice because of toxins in her apartment.
(Democracy Now, January 17)
- Parents Vent Anger Over
School Dust
(Daily News, January 17) Parents at Stuyvesant High School
are fed up with how the Board of Education and the city have
handled air quality problems at the school since the World Trade
Center attack. When school officials reopened Stuyvesant on Oct.
9, they assured parents that a thorough $1 million cleanup had
been conducted and that extensive testing showed the school's
3,000 students faced no health risks. Soon after the reopening,
however, several students came down with severe respiratory problems.

- Is 'Ground Zero' Toxic? (United Churches of Christ Disaster
Alert, January 15) Asthma attacks, headaches, nosebleeds,
sore throats, hacking coughs, bronchial infections, rashes. People
who live near ground zero are taking these symptoms to their
doctors, and for workers still clearing rubble, it's even more
serious. Firefighters call it the "World Trade Center cough,"
and four Port Authority police officers were reassigned from
the site after they tested positive for elevated mercury levels
in their blood. For the full text of this article, reproduced
as part of NYCOSH in the News,
click
here, or to view it on the original website click on:

- Health
Checks at Ground Zero: Cleaning Workers Flock to Mobile Medical
Unit (Newsday,
January 15) Dozens of fearful workers who cleaned buildings
in lower Manhattan after the World Trade Center attack lined
up outside a mobile medical unit yesterday to be tested for respiratory
problems and toxic exposure. Even before the van opened its doors,
the mobile clinic had scheduled 52 appointments for the week.
In addition, about 50 other workers complaining of headaches,
chest pains and a wide range of other problems crowded around
the van in the cold, desperate to be tested. For the full
text of this article, reproduced as part of NYCOSH in the News, click
here, or to view it on the newspaper's own website click
on:

- As the World Trade Center
Clean-Up Continues, Health Concerns Grow (NYCOSH Update on Safety
and Health, January 14) Despite the passage of four months
since the World Trade Center attack, public expressions of concern
about potential health hazards resulting from the twin towers
collapse are on the increase. In response to long articles in
the Wall Street Journal and the Washington Post listing examples
of unexplained sickness among workers and area residents, on
January 9 the Inspector General of the Environmental Protection
Agency opened an investigation of how EPA had responded to questions
about air quality in the aftermath of the attack. "If the
allegations reported in the Washington Post are true, EPA has
done a disservice to the brave men and women working at 'ground
zero' and to the citizens who live in the area whose health and
environment we are required to protect," Inspector General
Robert Martin wrote in his first statement concerning the investigation.

- WTC Day Laborers to Get
Toxin Tests
(Associated Press, January 14) Immigrant day laborers
have performed thousands of hours of work removing debris from
downtown office and apartment buildings since the Sept. 11 terrorist
attacks, many without proper protective gear and most without
health insurance. Starting Monday, the workers can get free physical
exams and be tested for health problems at a mobile health clinic
parked near City Hall. For the full text of this article,
reproduced as part of NYCOSH in the News, click
here, or to view it on the newspaper's own website click
on:

- Battle
Over EPA Denials of Dangers Downtown (Daily News, January 12) Environmental
Protection Agency brass found themselves sharply at odds yesterday
with the agency's proposed investigation into charges that the
EPA concealed evidence of dangerous contamination at the World
Trade Center disaster site. At issue were assurances from EPA
chief Christie Whitman and other agency officials that environmental
conditions at the site were safe even as agency tests
showed dangerous warning signs.

- Tragic Mound, Toxic Ground (MSNBC, January 11) Four
months ago, Sept. 11 marked the tragic loss of thousands of lives
in an unprecedented terrorist attack on U.S. soil. The event
may also be the biggest environmental disaster to ever hit New
York City or any densely populated area in America for
that matter. Now, some experts are calling for Ground Zero and
surrounding neighborhoods to be designated a federal toxic waste
site.

- Mobile Medical Unit To
Care For WTC Recovery Workers
(New York 1 News, January 10) A new mobile medical
unit will track the health of workers cleaning up in the vicinity
of the World Trade Center site. Beginning Monday, the "World
Trade Center Mobile Medical Monitoring Unit" will be based
near City Hall Park. It will provide medical examinations for
workers, focusing on respiratory and other health problems they
may face from coming in contact with potentially toxic substances.

- In
N.Y., Taking a Breath of Fear: Illnesses Bring New Doubts About
Toxic Exposure Near Ground Zero (Washington Post, January 8) There
was something about the air. For a while after Sept. 11, George
Tabb and his wife tried to stick it out in their apartment just
north of the World Trade Center, tried to ignore his twice-nightly
asthma attacks and her pounding headaches. Eventually, they moved
in with Tabb's stepfather. But Tabb still goes home to pick up
his mail, and within 20 minutes the metallic taste returns to
his mouth, and the wheezing. "All of a sudden, boom, I've
got a nosebleed, the asthma, a headache," he said. Recently
Tabb received evidence that the air in his apartment may be as
dangerous as he suspects. Independent tests -- results of which
are disputed by the city -- found that dust taken from an air
vent in his apartment building's hallway contained 555 times
the suggested acceptable level for asbestos. Samples from a bathroom
vent show dangerous levels of fiberglass.

- The Air Downtown: Tests
Call it Clean, But Coughs Abound (New York Observer, January 7) The
fire where the World Trade Center once stood is extinguished;
the city has erected a viewing platform for the benefit of ground-zero
tourists; and former Mayor Rudolph Giuliani has already outlined
his vision for a grand monument at the site. It has become a
point of pride for leaders of the city, the state and the nation,
determined to put a brave face on things, that the scene of the
Sept. 11 attack has become an almost normal part of the New York
landscape. But many of the elected officials who represent the
areas hit most heavily by the events of Sept. 11, as well as
some experts who were charged with examining the fallout, have
been urging just about anyone who will listen to take a closer
look at what is happening in lower Manhattan. They say that the
understandable quest for normalcy carries the risk of papering
over potentially hazardous problems, including contamination
by asbestos and a potentially toxic cocktail of materials thrown
together after the collapse of the towers. In addition, several
scientists who researched the contamination issue called into
question some of the conclusions reached by the government about
the environmental safety of areas around the World Trade Center.

- Mercury
Concern at WTC: Blood Levels in 4 Cops Raise Call for New Tests (Daily News, January 5) Workers at Ground
Zero called for more comprehensive health tests yesterday after
four Port Authority police officers assigned to the site showed
elevated levels of mercury in their blood.

- At Least a Quarter of Ground Zero Firefighters
Ill A
quarter of the 6,500 firefighters who have worked at ground zero
after the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center have respiratory
ailments, and 100 to 200 are exhibiting serious symptoms that
may allow them to retire on a disability pension, Fire Department
officials said yesterday. Representatives of the firefighters'
union gave even higher estimates of the number who are ill. Thomas
Manley, sergeant-at-arms and health and safety officer for the
Uniformed Firefighters Association, which represents 9,100 firefighters,
estimated that 4,000 firefighters are suffering from a persistent
cough and that 400 to 500 may end up being forced to retire.
Between 300 and 400 are on medical leave because they have a
chronic cough, get winded very easily or are coughing up a lot
of phlegm or a chalky substance, he said. None are hospitalized,
though one or two were in September, he said. (New York Times,
December 21)
- Hostile Environment Near WTC 100 or so protesters gathered
outside City Hall on Tuesday evening. For more than an hour,
several people in the crowd most of them middle-class
women and teenagers who looked unaccustomed to demonstrating
took turns recounting their ordeals since Sept. 11, telling
stories the leaders of our city find inconvenient these days.
"It's like we're screaming in the wind and no one listens,"
said Diane Lapson, who has lived at Independence Plaza in Tribeca
for nearly 30 years. For the last three months, Lapson and many
of her 5,000 neighbors at Independence Plaza have been unable
to sleep. Across from their complex of buildings is the pier
where Ground Zero workers load debris from the World Trade Center
disaster onto barges for shipment to a Staten Island landfill.
But it is not just the noise that's troubling. Even more worrisome
to the thousands living in lower Manhattan are their many unanswered
questions about possible health effects from toxic substances
in the air. (Daily News, December 20)
- City Had Been Warned of Fuel Tank at
7 World Trade Center
Fire Department officials warned the city and the Port
Authority of New York and New Jersey in 1998 and 1999 that a
giant diesel fuel tank for the mayor's $13 million command bunker
in 7 World Trade Center, a 47-story high-rise that burned and
collapsed on Sept. 11, posed a hazard and was not consistent
with city fire codes. The 6,000-gallon tank was positioned about
15 feet above the ground floor and near several lobby elevators
and was meant to fuel generators that would supply electricity
to the 23rd-floor bunker in the event of a power failure. Although
the city made some design changes to address the concerns
moving a fuel pipe that would have run from the tank up an elevator
shaft, for example it left the tank in place. (New York
Times, December 20)
- For many on Sept. 11, survival was no
accident
Four
hundred seventy-nine rescue workers died making the World Trade
Center evacuation a success. The sacrifice of New York firefighters
and police is well-known. But 113 others, from low-paid security
guards to white-collar workers at the Port Authority of New York
and New Jersey, the buildings' owner, stood their ground with
firefighters and cops. Nearly everyone who could get out did
get out. (USA Today, December 19)
- Residents Rally Over Air Quality In Lower
Manhattan
More than 100 downtown residents gathered on the steps of City
Hall Tuesday night to protest what they say is unsafe air quality
in Lower Manhattan. Many of the protesters say the air downtown
is still making residents, students, and workers sick. They want
city officials to relocate the removal of debris away from large
housing complexes. (New York 1 News, December 18)
- Bosses Try to Ease Ground-Zero Fears Merrill Lynch & Co. medical
director Donald Gemson briefs everybody on the latest scientific
findings on asbestos and other airborne hazards. His bottom line:
There's no long-term health risk, but employees may experience
watery eyes or sore throats. "We don't tell them that it
is going to be perfect," he says. (Wall Street Journal,
December 14)
- Trade Center's Fireproofing Had a Questionable
History
Engineering experts involved in studying the World Trade Center
disaster are now closely examining the spray-on fireproofing
used on much of the steel framework of the twin towers to determine
whether it contributed to their collapse. (New York Times, December
14)
- Medical Aftershocks The death toll from the World
Trade Center disaster now hovers around 3,000, about half the
early estimates. But there is evidence that the final tally may
rise over time, as the long-term effects of working at Ground
Zero take their toll among rescuers and volunteers. Those at
greatest risk are the thousands of firefighters, police, emergency
personnel and volunteers who streamed to the devastation in the
hours, days and weeks after the twin towers collapsed. Working
round-the-clock, with little or no respiratory protection, these
men and women inhaled a soup of dust, gases, burning chemicals
and potentially toxic compounds. (motherjones.com, December 10)
- WTC Dust Makes Some Ill
Ever since the big gray cloud of dust blew through Lower
Manhattan from the collapsing World Trade Center's Twin Towers
Sept. 11, there have been conflicting opinions on what to do
with it. The dust from the pulverized walls, concrete, wood,
class and plastic of the two 110-story Twin Towers covered several
blocks surrounding the World Trade Center. "On Sept. 11
the dust cloud was like a sonic boom through Lower Manhattan
-- my windows were open so my apartment near the World Trade
Center got filled with dust," said Indira Singh, a risk
architect and volunteer emergency medical technician told United
Press International. "I started noticing that many of my
neighbors are getting sick." (United Press International,
December 7)
- Air Quality: Ground Zero It's been three months since
September 11th and the tricky task of cleaning up Ground Zero
continues. Just a few days ago, part of the site had to be evacuated
when workers accidentally punctured several dry cleaning containers
uncovered in the rubble. The EPA feared a release of dangerous
ammonia vapor, but the damage was contained. Over all, though,
air quality in lower Manhattan has become something of a controversy.
Government agencies say it's safe, but others who live and work
in what's called "the breathing zone" remain unconvinced.
(National Public Radio's Living on Earth, December 7)
- Senator Clinton Calls For Senate Hearing
On Environmental, Health Concerns At Ground Zero: Senator Reiterates
Concern About Potential Long-Term On December 4, at a Senate Environmental
and Public Works (EPW) Committee hearing, Senator Hillary Rodham
Clinton (NY) called on the Committee to hold a hearing early
next year to examine possible environmental health problems at
and around Ground Zero in lower Manhattan. (Press Release, December
4)
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.

Compensation (December 2001- January
2002)
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.
For links material published after January 31, 2002, click
here.
- Federal Fund Shuts September
11th Victims Out?
(WNYC News, January 31) Families of those who died
in the September 11th terrorist attacks are not the only ones
unhappy with the proposed rules for the federal victims' compensation
fund. The injured are opposed to the fund's so-called "24-hour-rule."
That rule allows them to apply for compensation only if they
sought medical help within 24 hours of being hurt or rescued.

- WTC Disaster Assistance
Application Deadline Extended to March 11 The director of the Federal Emergency
Management Agency (FEMA) announced the extension of the deadline
to apply for federal and state disaster assistance. The new deadline
of March 11, 2002, was requested by the New York State Emergency
Management Office (SEMO) to ensure that all individuals who suffered
losses from the Sept. 11 attack have access to the assistance
programs.
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.

Government resources (December 2001-
January 2002)
(FOR OFFICIAL INFORMATION ON A SINGLE SUBJECT,
SUCH AS ASBESTOS OR COMPENSATION, SEE THE SUBJECT)
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.
For links material published after January 31, 2002, click
here.
- OSHA Standards Interpretation
Letter Wherever
there is settled dust from the collapse, "proper precautions"
include compliance with the OSHA asbestos standard: "In
that the materials containing asbestos were used in the construction
of the Twin Towers, the settled dust from their collapse must
be presumed to contain asbestos. Therefore [testing of the dust]
is not necessary in order to establish that the applicable provisions
of the Construction Asbestos standard apply during the demolition
or salvage of affected structures."
(January 31)
- Environmental Law Issues Raised by Terrorist
Events in 2001
A speech by
Walter E.Mugdan, Regional Counsel, U.S. Environmental Protection
Agency Region 2, January 25, 2002
- Nadler
Exposes Dramatic EPA Double-Standards and Mishandling of Hazardous
Materials Testing and Removal in Downtown Manhattan Residences:
Calls for Full Testing and Cleanup, Comprehensive and Independent
Investigations
(Press Release, January 17) Calling into question the
integrity of the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA) actions
in lower Manhattan since the World Trade Center attacks, Rep.
Jerrold Nadler exposed a gross disparity in how the EPA has responded
to the aftermath of the 9/11 attacks compared with other instances
of hazardous materials contamination around the country. Congressman
Nadler made the announcement at a City Hall press conference
and was joined by members of the Ground Zero Elected Officials
Task Force, and Hugh Kaufman, Chief Investigator for the EPA
National Ombudsman.
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.

News features (December 2001- January 2002)
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.
For links material published after January 31, 2002, click
here.
- Track Their Health Now,
to Protect Others Later (Washington Post, January 20) Twenty
years from now, will the World Trade Center disaster continue
to claim victims? Will the tragedy be compounded by a loss of
life that had less to do with terrorism than with ignorance?
In the haste to return Lower Manhattan to a sense of normalcy,
have additional lives been put at risk? For the full text
of this article, reproduced as part of NYCOSH in the News, click
here, or to view it on the newspaper's own website click
on:

- Environmental
Law Implications of the World Trade Center Disaster The horrific loss of life and
the ensuing global war against terrorism are by far the most
important aspects of the events of September 11. Less significant
but worth discussing are the environmental impacts. The destruction
of the World Trade Center probably had greater short-term environmental
impacts than anything else that has ever happened in New York
City; the long-term effects remain to be seen. This article is
devoted to analyzing how environmental law bears on the physical
aftermath of this catastrophe response, recovery and reconstruction.
(Environmental Law in New York, January 2002)
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.

Occupational safety and health resources
(December
2001- January 2002)
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.
For links material published after January 31, 2002, click
here.
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.

Psychological trauma (December 2001-
January 2002)
For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.
For links material published after January 31, 2002, click
here.
- Victims at Risk Again:
Counselors Scramble To Avert Depression, Suicides After Sept.
11 (Washington
Post, December 19) The first suicide was last week, the
widow of a World Trade Center victim who shot herself at her
Pennsylvania farmhouse. It was a tragedy that relief workers
had braced for -- a spike in depression, substance abuse, divorces,
suicides -- the sad legacy among those touched by the Sept. 11
terrorist attacks. Warned by a pattern that emerged after the
Oklahoma City bombing, public officials and charities have taken
perhaps the most aggressive stance ever in pushing mental health
therapy for families and others affected by the attacks.

For links material published
before December 1, 2001, click
here.
The “This page was last updated on” line just below reflects the date on which this page was transferred to this redesigned website. The information in this page (as opposed to the design) was last updated on April 15, 2002.
|
|